Custom Search

Wednesday, November 11, 2009

Am I My Really My Sisters' Keeper? Pt. 1

The good thing about continuing to be on this Earth another day is the opportunity to continue learning and growing. Those are things I try to do and things that I sometimes do in spite of myself. I've recently learned, or perhaps been reminded, that continual criticism of others without honest self-analysis isn't gonna get you far. Just something to think about, my friends.

A big piece of my writing and my public war, as you know, is men: misogyny, sexism, patriarchy, privilege. Some of y'all think I have armpit hair down to my knees, I'm sure. And I feel that my criticisms and issues as they relate to gender are valid. That's why I have them. However, as I unpack the issues I have with members of the opposite sex as they relate to love and romance, I must also look at the womenfolks and what we are doing wrong (in both our actions AND our criticisms).

A lot of people settle for being "right". They feel like winning an argument is a victory. I don't want to be America's Next Top Right Person. What's the sense in that? We pat ourselves on the back for recognizing racism and sexism that our racial or gender counterparts don't see. Okay, but now what? The point isn't to be the rightest person, but to change the world...right? Well, sometimes we gotta change ourselves too. No matter how marginalized or oppressed we are, we are still human flawed and sometimes just dead wrong.

Self-reflection is hard. Self-awareness is hard. Criticism of others? Eh, not so much. We can pile up complaints on other folks all day long without breaking a sweat, present company included. Now, constructive criticism isn't always easy; it requires a delicate convergence of emotion and fairness, honesty and thoughtfulness AND (if delivered properly) sensitivity.


How many of us are truly Tresevanty? Tell the truth, shame the devil.

That said, I am seeing some behavior in my sistren and myself that I find to be detrimental to our alleged goal of creating happy, loving relationships with men. Now, it's hard to be yet another voice telling women "Love: you are doing it wrong". There's millions of dollars grossed yearly thanks to the belief that women need to be reading and studying and obsessing over how to get a man, how to be ready to get a man, how to keep a man, how to sleep with a man. Women are telling us how. Men are telling us how.

I'm just not even gonna say anything.

I don't need to revisit the long repeated criticisms found in magazines and books about not learning to love ourselves first or trying to fix a "no-good" man. I have some other observations that are weakening not only our arguments about the things that men do wrong, but our ability to be the stand-out lovers and sisters we all seem to think we are. These are a couple of things I have peeped from sisters on the Twitter and in the real-life streets lately that I want to call out. A few today, a few more in the future.

1)It's Not Her. It's That You Are Not Her
Say I like a man named Marcus. We used to date, but he moved on and I didn't. Torch carrying game proper. Say Marcus begins dating a stunning model who I feel is prettier than me. I tell everyone who will listen how superficial he is. Now, say that Marcus instead starts dating a frumpy, no-style schlub. Now everyone has to hear about how wack she is and how I don't get what he sees in her. Sense, this does not make and how many times have we heard the SAME woman make these two very different complaints? You can substitute complexion, body type, socio-economic class for the things listed above as well. At the end of the day, the greatest criticism we have of our desired one's chosen one is the fact that they are not us. Do men do it? Absolutely. But I hear women doing this far more often: shaming men for being shallow in one breath, and then complaining about guys choosing "ugly" women in the next.

2) What Are We Asking For Again?
One of the biggest criticisms of the various feminist movements throughout time: women who seem to be chasing not equality, but male privilege. Wanting not balance, but the same access to be awful and oppressive to others. I, again, defer to Paolo Frere's theories on this. Well, even amongst decidedly "not" feminist women, there is a sentiment that condones dogging men out because it's been done to us. I don't mean direct retaliation against former lovers (which could actually be fair or even productive, depending on the cleverness of the vindictive woman). I'm talking about "Girl, I treat these men like they treat us. Okaaaay?"


Again...no comment.

Two can play the game, but we aren't really adding more wins to the overall cause. There's a big difference between being a strategic and choosy dater as opposed to a user and an asshole. The last thing women should do is try to deliberately emulate the worst in male behavior. It doesn't help anyone, just adds more jerks to the already booming suckery we have amongst us. Why? Using men for sex or two-timing them is not gonna undo whatever pain you or your mother or less 'savvy' friends may have experienced. All it's gonna do is create more ugliness in the world. Which we don't need. The world is plenty ugly as it is.


PLENTY!

In the interest of time, I'll stop here. I've got more, trust me! If I am the sister warrior-lover I believe I am, I have to look in the mirror and I have to look at my girls and challenge us when I think we are wrong. This is an ongoing personal project and I hope we can grow together, folks.


14 props:

Don said...

I tend to agree with your statement concerning settling for being right. I think society is programmed this way. I suppose people figure if a person is wrong, then they are just wrong. But, if you ask me, it's much more deeper than this.

I am impressed with your ability to convey thought so deadly yet eloquently.

BoSoxQT said...

"One of the biggest criticisms of the various feminist movements throughout time: women who seem to be chasing not equality, but male privilege."

As a woman who believes in fighting for women, this ALL day. Some of those in the fight seem to carry this mentality as some sort of divine manifesto. I don't WANT to be a male nor do I want to have male privilege. Equality does not mean the same. I just want to be able to make choices and not be judged by a different standard for making them because I pee sitting down. I happen to like being a female, thank you. Honestly, if you're striving for dominance (which is another form of the envy you've also mentioned) then you are no better than those who oppress you and those like you. At least that's what I take from it.

Once again, you articulate what I think but cannot say. If someone ask me to write a book one day (and considering the folks getting book deals, I have a chance dammit), I might have to hire you as my not so ghost, ghost writer.

P.S. Nothing wrong with some Ralph. I may have "Do What I Gotta Do" on my current play list.

HotNix said...

I've been reading you for years and don't think I've ever commented, but, today, you did it. I wholeheartedly endorse what you said in it's entirety. Love your thing!!!

IntrospectiveGoddess said...

LMAO@the picture of gucci mane, is he foaming at the mouth. I agree with these critiques women contradict ourselves quite a bit. I think I agree the most with the last point made, it would make sense if you treated the guys that treated you like shit in the same way but it makes no sense to treat every unsuspecting man in that way and in the end all it does is make you look like an asshole

J Danielle said...

I am IN LOVE with the word sistren. When you tweeted about this the other day I wondered if you'd address the way women critique the partners of those men in which they are interested. It's nice to see this post come from a woman who believes in women...made all the right points and without the "women hate other women and that's why they criticize" undertone that some use when they write about such matters.

Ms_Slim said...

Absolutely loved this blog as usual. Will be looking out for the next installment :)

Sasha said...

I sent you an e-mail about a previous blog. I'm not sure if you got it. Can you please give me your e-mail...I have a question but I don't want other readers to see the question.

Lite Bread said...

“Some of y'all think I have armpit hair down to my knees, I'm sure.”

Ms. Toldja,
I hope you know I wasn’t serious about the vision of you on your bicycle with the unshaven legs. It was more about how some people become like a caricature of their personal “Cause”.
I know you’re not at all like that. If someone lacks the reading comprehension and wit to understand the complexity that is “you”, well, you can’t really help that.

I do wholeheartedly agree with you (and Don’s comment) that “winning” arguments accomplishes little. Often sets you back! I’ve watched so many times in my career someone push the “I’m Right!” – and they actually were – agenda, figuratively beating everybody’s head on the table with it, and lose! Fair or unfair, by tactlessly forcing the “OK, we’re Wrong” from others, they end up being resented, their ideas undermined or scrapped first chance anybody gets and everybody will henceforth avoid them.
Convincing people of something is a difficult, long-term end-goal that takes lots of, not just sensitivity, but patience and self-control. Take it from a full-time single Dad of teenagers! I have lots and lots of practice on trying to achieve the honest “buy-in” on some needed change or action.

As far as the ‘Women’ stuff, from the outside, I really don’t see much of the second one you mentioned. Maybe that’s a function of my age bracket, something more common with younger women. But I really haven’t met women who want to do the “dog” thing like males will. They may spread themselves around too much, but it will be for completely different reasons. Or maybe I’m subconsciously more selective than I’d guess.

OH, and BoSoxQT? You CAN pee standing up! Truth! I ran across a product called “GoGirl”, a device that enables the stand-up pee for females. Just an FYI, lol!

PKGM said...

Love it! As usual..ugh, now am I groupie yet? LOL!

It is unfortunate, but I feel that realization as to how WE are to be towards OTHERS...selfless and selfish at times doesn't come until a certain age...but at least it comes.

Last year on the eve of my 29th I had a mini epiphany: No matter how hard we try, we will never truly understand the game of human interactions! I fought the good fight for years...bending and changing for some and getting others to bend and change for me. Yup..it is all trial and error and many other clichés.

J give I(us)strength!

Sunset said...

Ralph Tresvant as an adjective, great visuals that require no comment, and excellent writing (as usual) all make you America's Top Toldja.
@ lite bread: I cannot deal with u and the "Go Girl". WHY do u know about that product?
BTW, Toldja, congrats on all ur recent opportunities to bring conference-goers and radio listeners into the Toldjadome. Exciting and inspiring!

Naomi said...

ohhh you should have warned us about the last picture! i swear for God I jumped up once i scrolled down!

yes we as sisters have ALOT to fix, myself included.

Shay said...

Folks in general have a lot to fix.

This is why I'm becoming a Psychologist. Job security...and human interaction is just so interesting.

You're an articulate young woman, Toldja. Props.

P.S.

Any word on the surprise? Or did the lovely mail room at Howard lose it?

Tracy said...

*Blink Blink* Um, loved it. But now feeling conflicted because I am an intellectual bully, ahem, but no longer fight every battle that crosses my war path (pick and choose, at least I am trying). Wonderful article. I just had to realize that I am NOT HER..which is a good thing considering the position that some 'hers' play. My no nonsense personality keeps my bed cold but my sanity (semi) in tact.

Lite Bread said...

Sunset?
Gives a Whole new twist to the expression “You Go-Girl”.