If the death of Michael Jackson was one of those rare unifying moments that brought people together en masse to mourn and reflect, it seems that Steve McNair's vicious murder will instead be a polarizing one. I know that I have offended/disgusted/disappointed a few people on Twitter with my thoughts regarding the killing, but I feel how I feel. It's also difficult to present an entire argument in 140 character bursts, so I thought I'd break down my personal feelings on my personal blog. If you don't wish to deal with them, the 'x' in the right hand corner will always be your friend.
Steve McNair, in my opinion, did not deserve to die. I know that some would disagree, because the Bible states "the wages of sin are death" (I thought that was just a cleaver Me'Shell N'Degeocello line for years, btw). I also know that a lot of other Christians who are usually quick to jump up and down and extol the "sins" of gays and others, even in the face of their murder, are unusually quiet on this matter. I have heard (primarily from Black men) "We didn't know what was going on with him and his wife." Well, we know one thing that was: adultery.
I'll say it again so people understand that I mean it: barring some as yet exposed evidence that he had physically terrorized this woman in some way, Steve McNair did not deserve to die. Under my code of morality, what he did wrong was not something that merited death as a punishment. HOWEVER, it is because McNair broke his covenant with God and his wife and took on a disturbingly young girlfriend (one who was a teen at the time of their initial engagement) that he is no longer here. We often consider divorce, financial turmoil, unplanned pregnancy, disease transmission and issues with one's children to be the primary consequences of an affair. However, as with any situation we place ourselves in, there can be unforeseen troubles that arise. Such is the case here.
We are too accepting of infidelity in this country. We seem to take for granted that most men- especially Black men and especially those of means- will cheat, are entitled to do so even! Face the facts: McNair made a choice that cost him his life, his wife a husband and his children a father. It so happened that he died by the gun, so people find it easy to ignore his culpability. What if she had given him AIDS or if they had died the night she got a DUI just days before the murder suicide? McNair gambled with the lives and safety of himself and his family and he lost.
And for anyone who wants to cry "victim blaming", this is the same as someone getting assaulted while robbing a house. It doesn't ignore the crime against the criminal, but we have to acknowledge that the victim wouldn't have been assaulted had they been where they were supposed to be and did what they were supposed to do.
As for this woman, while I can't help but wonder what was wrong with her to push her to such a heinous act, I do believe there has to be a special place in Hell for someone who steals a woman's husband and then steals his life. I wish she had just blown her own brains out. Well, I wish that she had been raised better, received the help she needed to deal with her own issues and that she had never been a trifling, low life whore. I'm sad for her two, to be so messed up at 20 years old is heartbreaking. And having a full grown man with money sniffing around your drawers and dangling Escalade keys isn't the sort of remedy she needed. What a pathetic woman, to kill the father of four children...for what?
When you get married and/or procreate, you can no longer live your life for yourself. You have greater commitments to honor. The things a single person can do, like taking up with a crazy young broad, should be no more. Your decisions impact not only your own life, but the lives of those who love and depend on you. I wish Steve McNair to rest in peace, but more so, I wish he had chose wiser. And I hope that people learn from this instance and realize the weight your choices can have.
Tuesday, July 07, 2009
I'm Still Struggling
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)


17 props:
I agree with the idea of saying he aint deserve to die. He deserved to give up over 50% of that bread. He deserved to have his life become a living hell. Hell, he may have even deserved some type of STD. However, me, you or no one else on this earth should be deciding who lives and who dies. But I think we have to be careful of the implications of your argument if we make it universally applicable. I think we would be blaming rape victims who dress provocatively. We would feel less sympathy for those who die in the line of duty. I'm a follower of the school of thought of "rule" philosophies vs. "act" philosophies, which state that we determine the morality and acceptability of something by applying them to general practices vs. specific acts so that may skew my opinion a bit. The fact that he's my frat brother may do the same also.
However, I do agree that people really need to consider the worst case scenario before they take actions like these.
PS We almost met this weekend. Close but no cigar :-(
As a self-avowed feminist, I am surprised at your harsh words for the young woman. You state she "...stole a woman's husband..." - WHAT!!!??? If anything McNair stole Keith Norfleet's girlfriend. If you read the stories, they were together for four years and broke up about five months ago - well McNair met her six months ago - you do the math. McNair decided to sew his royal oats - don't dawg the woman out for that.
From where I sit, he met the (YOUNG) chick; wined and dined her, and she stupidly thought that they had a future together (maybe he made her think that, maybe he didn't); when she realized that they had no future together, she overreacted and I guess decided her life was over and decided to take him with her.
I think maybe McNair started feeling old and stale and wanted to spice up his life and feel young again. Kazemi was just the remedy. Unfortunately he forgot to think about how stupid and impressionable young people are. This young lady probably thought of him like God.
This story was definitely a tragic one, and hopefully we men will learn from it - but I know we won't.
..and for everybody that always wants to talk about the sanctity of marriage - think about it. I personally think that marriage is unnatural. To spend the rest of your life waking up, talking to, going to sleep with, and generally sharing your whole life with ONE PERSON can get stale and monotonous. I am making this statement as a man that has been married for going on thirteen years and a man that has never been involved with infidelity.
Steve McNair's spirit may have been stifled - maybe he wanted to "live a little", who knows.
...of course I take back everything I said if he was just a womanizer.
i don't get it, why does mcnair's girlfriend get harsher criticism in this instance? her being in that situation is just as much his fault as it is hers. he knew he was wrong for cheating on his wife but he did it anyway, and she knew it was wrong to go with a married man, but she did it anyway. how is she wrong more-so than he?
he didn't deserve to die though, and i don't understand why anyone would think that.
@ Victoria - She's more wrong because she ended someone's life
I'm torn by this post quite a bit, Toldja.
And not because I think you are wrong or bad or mean, but because I think bowing at the altar of fidelity is a huge mistake. It is not that I don't think people are capable of it. It is more that I think society expectations of fidelity create more problems than they solve. I don't think sexual infidelity automatically correlates with bad character or not loving one's partner or kids. This has everything to do with my belief that sex and love are separate, sometimes overlapping, things. I think the more we understand this, the healthy ALL our relationships can be.
I don't say this to excuse people who cheat. If you make a commitment, you should stand by it. I firmly believe it. But I often wonder if we'd be happier as a nation of people if we had a slightly more relativistic understanding of relationships. Meaning, we need to begin to embrace, understand, celebrate, and encourage multiple ways of loving. I believe people would take fidelity more seriously if they made that choice of their own volition and with real understanding. The assumption that this kind of relationhip is the only kind worthy of recognition, the only kind where love and stability reign is wrongheaded and antiquated.
I also think there aren't enough facts made public yet for you to make some of the assertions you make here. As such, this seems to be more about your own frustrations than about McNair at all. That's worth interrogating, methinks.
All that said, you are right, he did not deserve to die. And really, that's all that need be said.
thank you for your well rounded view :)
I haven't read people's opinions about this because - well I didn't know people had so many, honestly.
I'm surprised to read that there are people out there who think that he should have died?
Everyone falls short, and by grace we are all here. So if his sins say his life should be taken... Well that doesn't bode well for the rest of us.
I can definitely see where you are coming from by saying: if McNair would have been acting 'right' he wouldn't have been caught up with a crazy young lady. But, there are married people out there who are murdered by their spouses. How was he to know that this particular young woman would be unstable? This same outcome could have been possible if he was single.
Would it have been less or more unfortunate had he been single? I'm not sure...
We all take chances when we deal with anyone in a relationship - whether we are single or not. It is most certainly heartbreaking for his wife and children. But sadly, there are really just some crazy people out there and it is regrettable that he ran into, and became caught up with one.
If anything, McNair is more wrong than her. Teenagers are stupid and they know nothing. McNair was a grown-ass man with all kinds of wisdom and life experiences. She was nothing but an impressionable youngster. Plus, let's not forget, he was STEVE MCNAIR - a legendary, superstar quarterback in the NFL. What impressionable young woman wouldn't want to be swept off their feet by him?
It is really sad that he (and she) died like that, but hopefully it won't be in vain. Hopefully someone can learn from this and have their life will be changed by this unfortunate event.
@Peyso - I don't think she is blaming McNair as much as she is citing his irresponsibility for his predicament. That isn't the same as blaming a rape victim for wearing provocative clothes because contrary to popular myth women don't get raped for wearing provoctive clothing, they get raped because some people are just rapists and considering how often it is people they know it isn't a situation of them not being where they are supposed to be. A better analogy would be if a woman was dressing provocatively and walks down a strip where there is prostitution and gets picked up by the police in that instance she may not deserve to be arrested but there is better judgement that could've been excercised.
@2
[You state she "...stole a woman's husband..." - WHAT!!!??? If anything McNair stole Keith Norfleet's girlfriend.]
One doesn't really contradict the other however even though she was young at 19 you are generally considered responsible for your actions and she is old enough to know to respect marriage. They both were responsible for the relationship but it is still a fact that she stole a woman's husband.
As far as her getting harsh words well at the end of the day she is still a murderer no matter how impressionble she may have been at 19 and 20. So that goes along with here being with a married man; McNair is a cheater but she is a cheater and a murderer and honestly killing someone makes the cheating look smaller. In any way that she was taken advantage of she went entirely too far in "getting him back".
There is also an article that says one of the reasons she was upset that he thought that McNair was with another women; I'm sorry but as the woman on the side you don't get to expect fidelity.
http://cnnwire.blogs.cnn.com/2009/07/08/mcnair-was-shot-by-woman-police-say/
Peyso- If we are going to use a rape anology, which I would prefer NOT to, then it would be like getting raped while you are burglarizing someone's house. You didn't deserve the rape, but what the hell was you out there stealing for.
I'm not saying he should have died. I'm saying he should not have had the affair that led to his death.
PS-I know! I had a blast with Maya though!
2- At 20 years old, I knew not to fuck someone else's husband. She has to accept her liablity for the affair and the murder. However, if the husband was stolen, that means he was up for the stealing. It takes two to tango and even with the seduction he may have performed...she should have avoided him like the plague. There are other men...shit, other ballers if that was her type, that she could have had.
If you don't believe in marraige for life, tell your woman. Dont get fucking married.
All- (And I think Omar summed this up well)I'm not blaming the side whore more for the affair than I am the whoremonger. HOWEVER, I'm not buying that "She was 19" bullshit either. He's disgusting for fucking with a girl that young and she was a whore for fucking a married man...and getting mad for him having other slideoffs! That stupid bitch can rot in hell! Sorry, feminism be damned! What a fucking waste of human space she was!
And for all these EXCUSES people are making for McNair, he didn't have a one or two time sexual affair with this woman. She was a side girlfriend. He paid her bills and took her on trips. You don't accidentally let that happen in a night of passion, you have to calculate and plot on shit like that.
Hi I've been reading you for awhile, its my first time commenting.
My thoughts on this are...
I think they were both wrong, but I feel that the person who is married is more to blame. The "other woman" didn't make a commitment to have and to hold anyone in sickness and in health etc etc. It is really up to the married individual to let others know they are taken and committed and off limits.
This whole story has me feeling sick to my stomach though. It's truly a tragedy that could have been avoided if these individuals had been A BIT more thoughtful about their decisions.
As far as those saying that this country needs to be more flexible about fidelity... if you wanna stick your dick in every Jane, Lane and Mary so be it, just roam free if that's your MO. But no, of course they don't want to do that, b/c muhfuggas want their cake and wanna eat it too!!! They wanna be in and out of every chick and have wifey waiting at home. I'm really tired of the rampant me me me attitude surrounding relationships and dating. You can't have it all, period.
Posting a bit later than the rest,but nevertheless,
Toldja, I have to disagree with you here.
While I think his actions as an infidel are diplorable, a major part of your argument really doesn't hold weight. There is no way to know that taking up a side girlfriend will end in death by gun plain and simple. If he got an STD or lost all his money, I think it'd be safe to say "you gambled and lost." But saying that you gambled and lost big time speaks to an unforseen consequence. Her actions are no different than if a platonic friend of yours decided to shank you after an argument over drinks. Sure, you took a risk by engaging in risky behavior- binge drinking, but that outcome was totally outside of the realm of normalcy. I'm not arguing the sanctity of marriage, or who's right or wrong in an affair- humanity is far to complicated for me to provide a blanket answer to a situation about which i have limited information. Instead, I'm saying cut the man a break.
also, you tagged this R.I.P. This is hardly letting someone Rest In peace....
i agree 100 percent with everything you said here.
regardless of whether or not you feel fidelity is unreasonable (which is a stupid fucking stance to take) you cant argue the fact that he made a vow, and broke it. with that being said, he still didn't deserve to get gunned down in his sleep.
and, like omar stated above, there's a big, big difference between being a "man-stealer" and a murdering man stealer. there's no excuse for that shit, and if there's a hell she deserves to be there.
--the champ
Post a Comment