Custom Search

Monday, June 01, 2009

It Has Always Been Around, It Will Always Have A Nitche


As I tend to be somewhat jaded about bad things that happen in the world...not at all disaffected, just rarely surprised...I didn't initially freak-out when I heard about the murder of abortion provider Dr. George Tiller. I was hurt to hear it, but hardly shocked. This is the kind of shit these devils do (much like the murder of Harlem police officer Omar J. Edwards by one of his colleagues). This land is wrought with people who will do whatever it takes to destroy the lives of women and people of color, both wittingly and subconsciously. Just because we have a Black, pro-female POTUS does not mean the country has moved past that.

However, when I really sat down at thought about it, I shed a few tears. Whether he was passionate about the meaning behind his work or if he simply saw the fiscal value in providing a service that many other doctors wouldn't is irrelevant. Dr. Tiller's work supported the legally protected right of women to decide whether or not they wish to give birth. The terrorist organization Operation Rescue (a member of whom is suspected to be the shooter) long since made the abortion provider a source of their attacks on choice and he was shot in 1993 by anti-choice lunatic Shelly Shannon.

The hypocrisy of radical anti-choice advocates is mind-boggling. If their argument against abortion is that it calls for humans to "play God" and decide when to end a human life, then how is it reasonable to end the life of an abortion doctor? It's enough to make your head explode. I understand the reasons for people being anti-abortion and I think that most women of any school of thought would prefer to go their days without having the procedure. But I find it deeply troubling that someone else would find it their place to decide what a woman can and cannot do with her body. And I find it horrifying that someone who is so passionate about the preservation of human life could take it upon themselves to end someone else's. But I don't find it surprising that these same folks are willing to do little to nothing to prevent the occurrence of rape (an event that would certainly make a woman consider abortion), as the safety of women doesn't seem to register high on their radar.

It shouldn't be so alarming, however, as anti-abortionists tend to be pro-death penalty. It is a matter of a group of people feeling that they should be the gatekeepers of life, that they are the ones who have the moral authority to decide whom shall be free to govern themselves and who doesn't deserve to live. My ire with the tendency of people to use religious texts to decide how the world should work is the assumption that everyone else reads these books the same way or has any interest or belief in them at all. Dr. Tiller read his Bible and worshipped just as his detractors did, but he felt justified in what he did for a living. And someone who saw things differently felt it was their place to end his life.

While Dr. Tiller was a man, his death is another casualty in the long-standing war of The World vs. Women. There are so many people (male and female) who believe (consciously and subconsciously) that women are somehow inherently incapable of being the makers and shapers of their lives. That left to our own devices, women are susceptible to destroying their existence or living without the appropriate level of morality. Jezebel recently discussed the large number of women who express their desire to bear sons and not daughters. I have personally always wanted sons because I wanted to send children out into the world who live in contradiction to what society has typically seen from men. Sons, who like Dr. Tiller, would support the lives of women and grow up understanding the equality of the sexes and the need to work for that equality.

My thoughts are a little disjointed (likely by my anger and exhaustion) and I feel like they are sounding like "Feminism For Dummies". I wish I could do Dr. Tiller more justice with my words, but I'm not finding them so easily as I'd like. Le sigh.

I'll leave you with a song that I posted early in my blogging career. I first heard this as a young girl and didn't quite understand it's weight. When I got to high school, I fully processed the words and was touched by the existence of a pro-choice anthem penned and performed by a man, when so much of the anti-choice movement seems to be an extension of patriarchal notions of masculine control over women's bodies. Hearing a Black man express such feminist ideology (when feminism has long since been labelled by my community as "White women's business" and the heavy influence of Christianity has rendered a lot of Black folks so fanatical about De Bible that they have voted for right-wing loons like George W. Bush in order to prevent THE GAYS from marrying and THE WOMEN from having choice) was also an OMG moment for me.

Digable Planets- "La Femme Fatal" (1993)


RIP Dr. Tiller. I will honor your memory by working to protect the continued ability for women to choose. And for those who oppose abortion, I'd suggest that you take Obama's advice and work to lessen the number of women seeking abortions by working to support pregnancy prevention education and anti-rape efforts.


8 props:

possumstew said...

LOVED it. I think we're all still a little stunned by both the shootings mentioned in this post. When you make it your business to enact change by combatting social ills - in your life, in your work, or wherever - it is always disheartening when awful things happen back to back to back. (I believe the term is "clusterfuck" - please pardon my French). Anyway, keep on keepin' on.

GOODENess said...

everytime i think of CHOICE I thkn of this song...I will never understand why eople protect one life and condemn another...the hypocrisy of their ideals makes me angry...If you have never been in a position where your CHOICE was called into question...you don't have the experience to protest something that is solely theorhetical for you!

Shawnta` said...

Great song. Great post.

This murder is awful (as are most...okay, okay, all murders).

This was definitely not the way to make a point or bring attention to what the anti-abortion people believe in. This killing did nothing to progress the Right to Life (RTL) movement. If anything, it set the entire movement back because of all the negative attention it is now getting. Of course there are extremists in any group but this shooter is seriously deranged. To be so opposed to a doctor performing a surgery to end life but you shoot him and end his life? In a church no less, where most of the RTL arguments are based. It's even crazier when I think that (according to one report) he was shot in the arm before years ago outside of his clinic. Isn't one of the beliefs in the RTL campaign that "Murder is murder"?

Grant said...

Dearest Toldja,

Though you felt as if you could not adequately get you thoughts out in totality, I like your point of view stated here. I, unlike many religious loons, have no problem saying publically that I do not hold the same stance as you on the issue of abortion, but not for many of the reasons others would try to shoot you down with.

I think you are right in saying that a lot of theses types of discussions (and often arguments) come from a “The World v. Women” or “The World v. People of Color.” However, when it comes to abortion in this country, I do not think it rests as an attack on women’s rights and abilities [solely] anymore. This shooting clearly was not done in the interest of trying to protect any religious/cult belief. This was simply hate (*cues up “Belief” by John Mayer). On this issue, many have clearly twisted their personal/religious/spiritual beliefs toward belief that such an action is the acceptable response to someone whom you disagree with. This is one of the greatest (among many) flaws of this country. We want to welcome different ideas and perspectives until the stand in contrast to those “we” (those in the majority) believe are “right.” I’m not suggesting we all believe the same thing about everything, yet learn how to better deal with our differences.

Also, hopping back on gender, a male was the one who killed Dr. Tiller. As a male myself, I will never experience what it is like to have to go through such a procedure. But, if men of the beliefs of the shooter are in such ardent opposition to abortion, they should do as you and Obama have suggested and do a better job at loving and protecting the women around them so that they do not ever have to consider abortion as a option (or necessity).

Again, I do not support abortion personally but I don’t support hate and ignorance either. We can fight and make all the laws we want but people are still going to do what they want to do (i.e. people sell and smoke weed everyday, now don’t they?). God gives every person on this planet the ability to chose to do things in life everyday. At the end of it all, the U.S. lawmakers will not be who we have to answer to about those decisions made.

Nomad said...

Outstanding post. It is sad that people are unable to express their views and disagreement with someone without violence. This is just an example of fanatics and zealots resorting to a primitive measure to stop a natural born right, free choice. I am pro-choice and against the death penalty. As I feel that we should never deny anyone the right to choose whether or not they want to bring another person into this world. Many people use religous text and other doctrine to argue their point. Fine it's perfectfully fine to disagree with someone resorting to cold-blooded murder is primitive and another example of backward minded thinking.Society has taken a black eye from this senseless killing but this won't be the last unfortunately. RIP Dr. Tiller. Long live forward minded thinking

Ms Sula said...

I couldn't agree more with your write-up. Instead of focusing on the women who decide what to do with themselves, could they please put that energy to help the overcrowded Foster System? All that money and energy could help save some kids from having to seek abortion!

My ire with the tendency of people to use religious texts to decide how the world should work is the assumption that everyone else reads these books the same way or has any interest or belief in them at all.I was raised catholic, and attend catholic church once in a while. I had to walk out in the middle of the homily a few times because the priest was focusing on Abortion as a reason to friggin' vote Republican. All the other issues did not matter. I find so condescendingly intrusive!! I am so passionate (read mad!) by this debate that I have a hard time formulating clear thoughts.

I hope the doctor rests in peace.

Those idiots!

NikkiBlue said...

I'm sorry thatI just got around to reading this blog but I would like to applaud you for what you wrote. It felt like the words were coming from my own fingers the way I totally 100% agree with your views. I was both shocked and saddened by the murder of Dr George Tillman. Thank you for putting into words what I am feeling about this tragic event and also about the actions and beliefs of many, if not all anti-choice supporters.

The Brown Blogger said...

Great post.

We must also hold folk like Greta Van Sustren, Bill O'Rielly and the folk over at fixed news who slandered Dr. Tiller and influenced folk all over the world to do something about it.

Proof that the suspected shooter bounced around certain forums and actually made comments about 'taking care' of the doctor based on the 'fair and balanced' reporting from the network as well as other media outlets.

Dr. Tiller's son even came out Monday and said that his works, writings and words were partially responsible for his father's murder.

Others haven't been so accepting in their roles in both the denial of women being viewed and accepted as whole and in the murder of Dr. Tiller.